A little while back I unsubscribed from a newsletter very much related to our own. I've always enjoyed reading that newsletter, and it has brought me several insights.So why did I unsubscribe then?
Even though the newsletter was great, the publisher had created a product he wanted to sell very much, so my e-mail box was loaded with many e-mails from him with just information about his new product. By doing this, I felt he totally disregarded the fact that I had given permission to send me his newsletter, not involve me in his sales scheme. So I decided to vote with my feet, and unsubscribed.
That could've been the end of that, but it wasn't.
On unsubscribing, I was asked to provide a reason for my departure. Because no-one can learn without feedback, I decided to tell him more about it:
"Hi,
I liked your newsletter, but I was turned off by your pushy marketing of your latest product.
I personally think there is a fine line between warm calling and cold calling. When looked at permission based marketing (which a newsletter basically is) you could consider the relationship with your visitors (me!) and the producer of the newsletter (you!) warm, and therefor any contact through that list would be considered warm calling.
However, each time when you contact your list, I think one should consider if this is what the subscriber gave permission for. Because, if that's not the case, it would simply be another form of cold calling, don't you agree?
Anyway, that's how I felt it.
So for me it's time to say goodbye. No hard feelings. I wish you all the best with your ventures."
End of story? Not.
The message bounced. It was sent to an e-mail address that wasn't checked, and the autoresponder said I could open a ticket through their help desk system. I still felt it important to share my thoughts (having written them already) so I opened a ticket and pasted my message in it.
I think they weren't too impressed with me, even though I had taken the time to share some feedback with them, because then i got this answer:
"Unsubscribed"
No "Thank you for your feedback" or just plain "Thank you". Just "Unsubscribed". And the ticket was closed.
But the system offered the option of reopening the ticket, so I decided to make sure it would go to the publisher: "Thanks, but I had already unsubscribed. As you can see my remarks was aimed at the editor of the newsletter, I trust you forward it to him?"
The answer this time was even shorter:
"--- do not reply ---".
What the .... ? Do not reply? Why have a system that offers rebuttle, and then tell your customer to not reply? Then it dawned on me. The "do not reply" text was added by the system to make sure that people did not reply to the ticket by e-mail. The girl from the helpdesk had just closed the ticket without further information. I guess she doesn't even know how the e-mail looks like when she does that. Maybe she doesn't even know there is a mail going out.
There are a few important lessons here:
- Make sure you know how you communicate with your customers. Automatic reply systems are not excluded.
- Only open up a communication channel with your (potential) customers, if you're willing to listen to them.